Jon Schneider is the founder of the Saturday Night Network, LateNighter’s podcast partner, and the author of our weekly “Five Storylines to Watch” previews. Having watched every episode of SNL dating back to 1975, he brings a lifetime of fandom and an encyclopedic knowledge of the show to this installment of “Hear Me Out.”
Ask a roomful of diehard Saturday Night Live fans to name the four greatest hosts in the show’s history, and you’ll get pretty far before the first argument breaks out. Alec Baldwin, Steve Martin, and Tom Hanks? Go ahead and start carving. It’s that fourth face that could keep everybody there all night.
For years, my answer has depended on whose episode I watched most recently. Catch Christopher Walken offering a woman a glass of champagne as the Continental and I’m ready to give him the spot. Watch Buck Henry show up at the Coneheads’ house as an Air Force investigator, and I start to reconsider. Give me five minutes with Justin Timberlake in a tofu costume singing “Bring it on down to Veganville,” and suddenly I’ve got a third answer.
So yes, there’s some danger in asking this question two days after John Mulaney hosted the best SNL episode in recent memory. I’m going to ask it anyway.
Did Mulaney just take that fourth spot? To answer that, it’s worth sizing up the competition before making the case for him.
Will Ferrell
If we were carving a Mount Rushmore of SNL cast members, the argument might be over who gets to stand next to Will Ferrell. His six turns as host raise a different question: How much of the excitement when Ferrell walks out comes from what he might do that night, and how much comes from the possibility that we might get to see Harry Caray, George W. Bush, or the guy who still needs a little more cowbell?
With Ferrell, I’ll happily count both.
Few alumni have that many characters and impressions people would love to see again. Fewer still could come back for a season finale with Paul McCartney and turn a longstanding resemblance to a rock drummer into a monologue worth remembering.
Tina Fey, a six-time host, and Kristen Wiig, a five-timer, would be my next two calls among returning cast members. Ferrell gets the edge because an entirely new sketch with him is as enticing as anything he could bring out of storage.
Melissa McCarthy
Think about what Melissa McCarthy had to work with the first time she hosted. A woman named Linda is invited to taste some ranch dressing. That’s the sketch.
Then you see how badly Linda wants to impress the people running this focus group, what she’s willing to do to get a little attention, and just how much dressing McCarthy can get down her chin. Fifteen years later, we can all still picture her face.
Across six episodes, McCarthy has made as good a case as anyone for being SNL’s greatest physical comedian among hosts. Give her a basketball practice to run, and suddenly the players have reason to fear for their lives. Give her a folding chair at a focus group, and she’s every bit as dangerous.
What I love about McCarthy is that she always seems to know exactly what her character wants. Everybody else in the sketch finds out how far she’ll go to get it at roughly the same time we do.
Scarlett Johansson
Scarlett Johansson has hosted seven times, more than any other woman in the show’s history. Her first episode aired in January 2006. Her seventh closed Season 50 in May 2025. She’s been part of the SNL family long enough that marrying Colin Jost feels like a relatively recent development.
Johansson’s great gift is how little the writers have to adjust an idea to accommodate her.
On her first visit, somebody saw a movie star and decided she ought to sell chandeliers with Fred Armisen. A year later, the two were back selling marble columns, and if you’ve seen that sketch, I’d wager you can still hear the way she says those two words.
There’s a generosity in giving yourself over that completely to someone else’s idea. It’s made Johansson one of the most adaptable hosts in SNL history and helps explain how she’s fit into so many different versions of the show over nearly 20 years.
John Goodman
For 11 consecutive seasons, Saturday Night Live booked John Goodman. He eventually hosted 13 times, a total that puts him behind only Baldwin and Martin. If the fourth spot goes to the person SNL itself most often wanted back, we have our answer.
I’d have a hard time putting all 13 of those episodes up against the best seven from Mulaney or Walken. Some Goodman weeks are much better remembered than others.
Still, there’s something to be said for the kind of host you can book every season without worrying about who’s in the cast or what the writers might have for him. For more than a decade, Goodman was that guy.
Justin Timberlake
It’s easy to forget that Justin Timberlake has hosted only five times.
Between the dancing mascots, the Barry Gibb Talk Show, and the two guys who put entirely too much thought into how to wrap a Christmas present, he left behind enough recurring material for somebody who hosted twice as often. Pair him with Jimmy Fallon or Andy Samberg, and you got a comedy partnership audiences would wait years to see again.
Timberlake would be my pick for the greatest double-duty host SNL has ever had. On those nights, you could go from the monologue to a live sketch to a Digital Short to the musical performance and feel like you’d spent the whole evening watching one guy find different ways to entertain you.
Consider who got the first few minutes of SNL’s 40th anniversary special. With four decades of cast members and hosts to choose from, the show sent out Fallon and Timberlake to put its history to music. By then, a kid who’d come to the show by way of a boy band had become somebody you could trust to tell its story.
Christopher Walken
Of the hosts with seven or more appearances, does anybody have a higher batting average than Christopher Walken?
The Continental alone would put him in contention. Add the cowbell sketch and those song-and-dance monologues, and you have a host whose greatest hits make almost no sense on paper together. Somehow, the guy who can make an offer of champagne sound like grounds for a restraining order is also the guy you want doing a little tap dance when he comes through the doors.
Then there’s the advantage Walken gave every writer in the building. You could hear exactly how a line would sound before you’d finished typing it.
His seventh monologue made particularly good use of that voice. Walken took questions from audience members, all of whom had been given their questions by Walken himself. When one woman asked his favorite color, he took her to task for wasting the opportunity.
I’m guessing you just heard him say it, too.
Buck Henry
Buck Henry last hosted in 1980, which means several generations of fans have grown up without ever getting to experience what it meant to have him back.
Here’s one way to appreciate the distinction. When the original SNL decided that anyone in America could enter a contest to host the show, who did they trust to introduce the finalists? The guy who, that very night, became the first person to host five times. He’d make it to ten before the original cast said goodnight.
Henry helped establish what the job could be. He could blend in with the ensemble, play a character as unsettling as Uncle Roy, or stand opposite John Belushi’s samurai and give his scene partner all the room he needed.
When Belushi accidentally cut Henry’s forehead with his sword, Henry got bandaged up and finished the show. By the goodnights, Belushi had his own head wrapped in bandages. Even a genuine injury ended with the host setting up a laugh for somebody else.
John Mulaney
What separates Mulaney from nearly everyone else in this conversation is how much of an episode he can build himself. During his five years on the writing staff, he and Bill Hader created Stefon, who gets my vote for the greatest correspondent ever to pull up a chair at the “Weekend Update” desk.
As host, Mulaney can resurrect an idea the show passed on years ago, write material for the current cast, and deliver some of the best stand-up monologues in SNL history. Saturday’s run about his generational differences with his father would have been the highlight of plenty of episodes. In this one, we were just getting started.
Back in 2010, Mulaney and Colin Jost wrote a sketch about a guy who makes the mistake of ordering lobster at a diner. It took Mulaney coming back as host in 2018 to get it on the air. By his seventh hosting appearance, fans know to expect a new musical every time he came through the door. This weekend, a horse-drawn carriage ride through Central Park somehow got us to Bowen Yang as Mary Todd Lincoln. Imagine trying to explain to the guys who wrote “Diner Lobster” that this is where that idea would take them.
But the best argument for Mulaney on Saturday night might have been the few minutes he spent trying to have a drink with his coworkers.
Ashley Padilla’s Kathy had already gotten the better of Jack Black last season. This time, Mulaney played Dave, the guy at the bar who couldn’t let another one of her interruptions go. Watch how much funnier Padilla gets as his patience runs out. On a night when Mulaney had an entire Broadway production at his disposal, he was just as valuable sitting across a table from somebody doing her signature character.
For all the things Mulaney can write for himself, one of the best reasons to keep bringing him back is what he can do for somebody else’s sketch—the part of hosting Buck Henry made look easy.
So did Saturday night settle the fourth spot? Ask me again after I’ve watched Christopher Walken as the Continental, or Buck Henry trading blows with John Belushi’s samurai, and I might have a different answer.
But if we were actually standing in front of that mountain, trying to decide whose face to carve next, I know who I’d be arguing for right now.