When you are a late-night TV host and the president of the United States is thrown into a rage by jokes you tell about him—so much so that his complaints inspire underlings to take action to try to drive you off the air—what do you do in response?
If you are Jimmy Kimmel, circa 2026: You go right on telling jokes about him.
“He’s completely out of touch, and that’s probably for the best. When he is in touch, it’s usually without consent.”
If you are Dick Cavett, circa 1973: Same.
During a show taped in the Senate Watergate hearing room, Cavett quipped: “When I sit in this witness chair, I feel guilty.”
Yes, more than half a century ago, Richard Nixon was trying to do the same thing to a previous ABC network late-night host, Dick Cavett, that Donald Trump has tried to do to ABC’s current late-night host, Jimmy Kimmel—only not in public. On one of the secret White House recordings, Nixon said of Cavett: “Is there any way we can screw him?”
To which his top aide, H.R. Haldeman, replied, “We’ve been trying to.”
Cavett is a late-night name that deserves to be remembered for more reasons than his badge-of-honor place on Nixon’s famous enemies list (he was mentioned 26 times on those White House tapes). His show made its reputation on its eclectic guest bookings, its storied place amid the counterculture of the late ’60s and early ’70s, and its overall tone, which relied less on hard comedy than the host’s personal wit and, most distinctively, erudition.
Cavett’s show was basically the honors class of late night.
The man himself, who, during his prime as host of a 90-minute competitor to the great Carson, was often described as “boyish,” is, astonishingly, turning 90 years old today.
Watergate fell in the midst of that run, and Cavett embraced it, doing numerous shows devoted to the scandal and booking a long roster of Watergate-related names, from Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein to G. Gordon Liddy and John Dean.
A show he did featuring a debate about the Vietnam War between John Kerry and a fellow Navy officer named John E. O’Neill was what inspired Nixon’s call to “screw” Cavett—and, in another century, set the stage for the Swift Boat attack ads that damaged Kerry’s presidential chances in 2004.
In later interviews, Cavett said it was never his intention to do political shows, merely to lead an “entertaining little talk show.”
He exceeded his expectations.
Cavett’s career path actually had roots remarkably similar to Johnny Carson’s. He was a child of Nebraska who started out doing magic. As a schoolboy, he even pursued a meeting with Carson after a radio show in Lincoln and was treated to a magic-centered conversation with the then-emerging comic star.
But Cavett veered off from there, for a while. He got a degree in drama from Yale, did some minor acting gigs, but wound up in New York as a copy boy for Time magazine. He was also a major fan of Jack Paar’s Tonight show.
Cavett contrived to meet Paar by getting a ticket to the show, turning up at 30 Rock early (it was and is a public building), going up to the sixth floor, and hanging around the men’s room until Paar walked out of his office for a pre-show visit to the facilities. Cavett waited outside and handed the host a Time envelope he had grabbed off somebody’s desk. It contained some jokes Cavett had written.
Then he sat in the audience and heard Paar actually use some of his lines. Cavett completed the gambit by getting in the elevator with Paar after the show and talking himself into a job.
Cavett became a staff writer. His most memorable line for Paar was a gag introduction for the famed actress Jayne Mansfield: “And here they are, Jayne Mansfield!”
Cavett stayed on the staff after Carson succeeded Paar. Then he segued into stand-up, became friends with Woody Allen, and did gigs around the country for a time. His most famous joke said a lot about his comic sensibility:
“I recently went to a Chinese-German restaurant. The food is great, but an hour later you’re hungry for power.”
Like David Letterman, Cavett’s first network talk show was in the morning, for ABC. It didn’t work, though the reviews hardly constituted a harsh critique; it was too sophisticated.
After a brief prime-time stint, ABC moved Cavett to late night in December 1969, replacing Joey Bishop. No show had a reasonable chance to take down the supreme Carson, but Cavett’s approach carved out a shrewd contrasting niche:
Don’t try to compete with Johnny on humor; just be consistently interesting.
Cavett had a high-level skill at conversation across a seemingly unlimited range of interests. He could do a tribute show about Noël Coward featuring the famed acting couple Alfred Lunt and Lynn Fontanne as easily as shows with Muhammad Ali or John Lennon and Yoko Ono. You might see him mix guests like Lillian Gish, the baseball pitcher Satchel Paige, and the artist Salvador Dalí, who arrived with an anteater on a leash that he casually tossed into Gish’s lap.
He talked comedy with Groucho Marx and Lucille Ball and music with Jimi Hendrix and Janis Joplin. He talked about acting with Laurence Olivier and Katharine Hepburn. He talked about filmmaking with Ingmar Bergman, Alfred Hitchcock, and Jean-Luc Godard. And he revisited Hollywood’s golden age with Judy Garland, Fred Astaire, and Gloria Swanson.
He talked about the Woodstock festival with several of the big names who had performed there, taping the show the afternoon after the concert ended. The guests included Grace Slick and the rest of Jefferson Airplane, David Crosby, and Stephen Stills. Stills still had Woodstock mud on his pants.
The show made news frequently, not only with its Watergate coverage. Judy Collins appeared and talked about testifying at the Chicago Seven trial and had some of her comments censored by ABC’s legal department, an act she protested to the FCC as a violation of her First Amendment rights. (The FCC sided with ABC.)
Norman Mailer appeared boozed up and bellicose over a review from fellow guest Gore Vidal and initiated an insult-fest, which degenerated into the author bragging about his intellect and mocking Cavett for reading from his “question sheet.” To which Cavett replied, “Why don’t you fold it five ways and put it where the moon don’t shine?”
Among the guests Cavett brought on for a full show was Marlon Brando, fresh from turning down his Godfather Oscar to protest the treatment of Native Americans and accompanied by representatives of three tribes. After the taping, Cavett went to a Chinese restaurant with the actor. As they were leaving, Brando, harassed by paparazzo Ron Galella, punched him in the face, breaking his jaw and knocking out five teeth.
The segregationist governor of Georgia, Lester Maddox, walked off the show after objecting to Cavett’s reference to bigots who had voted for Maddox.
Perhaps most famously, to Cavett’s chagrin, a wellness advocate named J.I. Rodale died in his chair on the set during a taping of the show. The episode, of course, never aired, but it gained so much notoriety that Cavett was forever after approached by people who said they remembered seeing it.
Cavett’s ABC late-night run wasn’t long. It ended in early 1975. His career continued with other shows, but the format remained the same. A dash of wit and a lot of smart talk.
Just what you would expect from a wise guy. Cavett earned that designation. And a reputation as one of the great hosts in the late-night hall of fame.
Birthday celebrations encouraged.
Get stories like this in your inbox: Sign up for LateNighter’s free daily newsletter.