Most bands spend years working their way up to a national television appearance. Sam and the Pink Notes skipped that part.
The group made its live debut Tuesday night on Jimmy Kimmel Live!, fronted by Sam Schmid, a retired Oklahoma optometrist who happens to be John Mulaney‘s father-in-law.
Performing an original song called “Yellow Rambler,” Schmid delivered a performance that made up in charm what it lacked in polish. And given the unlikely circumstances that brought him to the Kimmel stage, that seemed entirely appropriate.
The performance came after several hours of online speculation sparked by Mulaney’s wife, Olivia Munn, who teased that something “really unexpected” would happen on Kimmel’s show Tuesday night. Her cryptic Instagram video had fans theorizing about everything from Mulaney taking over Saturday Night Live to succeeding Kimmel himself. As it turned out, the big surprise was a little closer to home.
Mulaney, who appeared as Kimmel’s lead guest Tuesday, explained how the unlikely musical booking came together.
It started with a Christmas gift for Schmid, Munn’s stepfather.
Schmid had spent decades writing his own country songs, many of them with a group Mulaney described as “a bunch of drunk guys in the ’70s in Oklahoma that would go camp.”
“For Christmas, I got him a recording studio in Chicago, and we made an album of those original songs,” Mulaney explained.
He also assembled a band of professional musicians to back Schmid, including his brother-in-law Johnny, drummer Quin Kirchner, Everybody’s Live music booker Kevin O’Donnell, and guitarist Matt Gold.
The group recorded the album over two days immediately before Mulaney’s July stand-up show at Wrigley Field, with Mulaney joking that producing a country record was a convenient way to distract himself from the pressure of performing at the ballpark.
It was at the after-party for that show that Sam and the Pink Notes got their big break.
“I was talking to you and told you I just recorded a campfire country western album with Olivia’s stepdad, and you said the next time you come on the show, they’re going to be the musical guests,” Mulaney told Kimmel.
“That is true,” Kimmel confirmed.
There was one small problem: The band hadn’t played together since recording the album. They next played together on Monday night, just one day before their national television debut.
And then there’s the matter of the album itself.
Mulaney explained that he’s currently serving as the band’s manager, record label, and producer.
“This is an enormous conflict of interest,” he joked.
Asked why the album wasn’t available for purchase, Mulaney said he’s still sorting out the details with Schmid, who, despite being brand-new to the recording business, apparently has strong opinions about how his music should be released.
Kimmel held up what appeared to be a copy of the album, prompting a clarification from Mulaney.
“That’s a piece of cardboard,” he said. “Let’s be fair. That’s not even an album.”
“You’re right,” Kimmel said. “There is nothing in here.”
“And yet they’re on television tonight,” he marveled.
Watch Sam and the Pink Notes’ full Kimmel performance at the top of this post.