The Forgotten Comedy Pilot NBC Tried During SNL’s Uncertain Third Season

As impossible as it is to imagine today, there was a moment nearly 50 years ago when both Lorne Michaels and NBC were preparing for Saturday Night Live to sign off for good at the end of its third season.

“Enjoy the zany unpredictability of NBC’s Saturday Night Live while you can because it won’t be around next season,” wrote Daily Herald TV critic Diane Mermigas in October 1977, barely three weeks into Season 3.

NBC, she reported, was already preparing for a future without the show, using SNL’s off weeks to try out possible successors in its own time slot.

Michaels didn’t appreciate it.

“The cast and the writers of our show are very upset about it, and I think it’s callous of NBC to do it,” he told Mermigas. “It’s really an insensitive move by the network.”

There was an irony to the complaint: Michaels had already made clear that he intended to leave. “This will be the last season of the show,” he confirmed to Mermigas in the same interview.

Among NBC’s possible answers to the question of what came next was The Great American Laugh-Off, the brainchild of Laugh-In creator George Schlatter.

Schlatter had played an important role in Michaels’ own career, hiring the young Canadian comedy writer to work on Laugh-In in 1969. But stylistically, The Great American Laugh-Off represented a very different idea of what could replace SNL.

If Saturday Night Live carried the flavor of 1970s New York, Laugh-Off was conceived in the image of San Francisco. It was shot there, drew much of its talent from the city’s comedy scene, and traded SNL’s cool, deadpan sensibility for something broader, louder, and more overtly showbiz.

Rather than build around a repertory troupe like the Not Ready for Prime Time Players, Laugh-Off presented a parade of comics and novelty acts performing their own material. Among them were Wayland Flowers and his sharp-tongued puppet Madame, along with a young Robin Williams, still a year away from Mork & Mindy.

Many of the same performers would figure in Schlatter’s NBC revival of Laugh-In that same season.

YouTube player

At least one TV critic was wowed by Laugh-Off, with Steve Dougherty of The News-Press applauding the show’s “assemblage of young, unknown comics who, if they can keep it up, will be keeping America in stitches for years to come.”

Williams was singled out for his “Superman on drugs” routine, in which he mimed flying upside down while lying on his back across a bar stool (a bit he’d later admit he stole from comic Bill Kirchenbauer).

Don’t fret about losing Saturday Night Live, Dougherty consoled fans: “The Great American Laugh-Off is bound to perpetuate your weekend hilarity habit.”

Despite that gushing review, it wasn’t all giggles for The Great American Laugh-Off. Before it ever aired, Schlatter was complaining to entertainment journalists that NBC was censoring some of his best material.

The network cut a sketch by Duck’s Breath, an underground San Francisco comedy troupe, in which a nun, a bishop, and the Holy Spirit did their impressions of conception and contraception.

The premise sounds like textbook censor bait, but Schlatter said he didn’t understand the fuss. After all, SNL “had some pretty raunchy stuff on there,” he said, noting that Playboy publisher Hugh Hefner had hosted earlier that year. “I don’t think anything in Laugh-Off is raunchy.”

NBC’s Standards and Practices department considered Schlatter’s plea but rejected the sketch. The dispute probably didn’t hurt the show’s publicity, since Schlatter’s complaints made newspapers around the country in the week leading up to its airing.

Everyone involved seemed to expect Laugh-Off to have a future. At the end of the show, host Nancy Bleiweiss promised viewers, “You’ll be seeing a lot more of all of my friends—perhaps right here.”

But The Great American Laugh-Off might as well have been called The Great American One-Off. It only aired once, and the show made so little impact that Schlatter didn’t even mention it in his autobiography, Still Laughing.

It wasn’t NBC’s only experiment in SNL’s slot that season. The network also tried Off-Hollywood, a satire of Southern California living; Le Disco, a Studio 54-style musical showcase featuring the Village People; and a Doc Severinsen holiday special.

In the end, no replacement was needed.

Michaels’ original NBC contract ran for three seasons, and he had confirmed his planned exit in several interviews. The weekly grind of producing 90 minutes of live comedy had worn him down, and he wanted to direct movies.

But Season 3 turned out to be the show’s strongest yet. As Susan Morrison recounts in her biography of the SNL creator, Michaels’ childhood friend and Saturday Night Live musical director Howard Shore made an observation that helped persuade him to reconsider: “It’s too bad, because we’re just learning how to do it.”

Though Michaels dithered for months over whether to return, the uncertainty proved a pretty good negotiating tactic. His agent ultimately secured him a contract worth $750,000 a year—about $4 million in 2026 dollars—plus a fund to develop new shows.

That bought Michaels some security going into Season 4. The replacement-show question would return soon enough, however: After Season 5, Michaels and what remained of the show’s original cast—all of whom had signed five-year contracts—finally made good on their plans to leave.

NBC once again developed shows that could potentially succeed Saturday Night Live. This time, though, the network decided the show was worth keeping, even without Michaels at the helm.

Get stories like this in your inbox: Sign up for LateNighter’s free daily newsletter.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *