Brendan Carr’s FCC Pick Faces Senate Scrutiny Over Jimmy Kimmel Emails

Brendan Carr‘s pick for a seat on the Federal Communications Commission is facing new questions about her ties to internal FCC discussions involving Jimmy Kimmel—and whether she misled Congress about her work on media matters.

Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-N.M.) sent a letter to Carr Friday demanding internal emails, messages, and other records involving Danielle Thumann Severs, a senior counsel to the FCC chairman whom President Trump has nominated to serve as a commissioner.

At her November 10 confirmation hearing, Thumann Severs testified that she had not worked with Carr on media-related matters. But Luján says documents obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests tell a different story.

Among the records cited in Friday’s letter are two email exchanges concerning Kimmel.

The first, dated September 5, 2025, shows Thumann Severs among the recipients of an internal FCC email forwarding a complaint against Jimmy Kimmel Live! filed by the conservative Center for American Rights. The complaint was submitted nearly two weeks before ABC suspended the late-night program amid pressure from Carr.

A second exchange, dated September 18, 2025—the day after ABC pulled Kimmel off the air—concerned the flood of complaints the FCC was receiving from viewers upset about his suspension.

Luján is now seeking the complete correspondence, including any talking points or consumer response language developed by FCC staff, along with records of a telephone conversation referenced in the emails. He also wants to know who approved the agency’s response to the complaints.

As LateNighter previously reported, the FCC received nearly 1,600 viewer complaints during the Kimmel controversy. Our review of those submissions found that 62 percent primarily criticized Carr or the FCC, while fewer than 5 percent were primarily critical of Kimmel.

The controversy erupted after Carr publicly warned ABC and its affiliates that they could take action against Kimmel or face additional regulatory scrutiny. ABC suspended Jimmy Kimmel Live! on September 17 before reinstating the program the following week.

The Kimmel correspondence is just part of Luján’s inquiry. The senator is also seeking records concerning Thumann Severs’ involvement in the FCC’s approval of the Paramount-Skydance merger and its handling of complaints against CBS’ 60 Minutes. Previously released emails show that she reviewed and edited a draft letter concerning commitments Skydance made ahead of the merger’s approval.

In his Friday letter, Luján said the discrepancies between Thumann Severs’ testimony and the available records raise “serious questions” about whether she intentionally misled the Senate Commerce Committee.

The FCC has disputed those allegations. In a statement to Politico earlier this week, a spokesperson insisted that Thumann Severs’ testimony was truthful, saying Luján’s allegations mischaracterized the facts. Thumann Severs has acknowledged that her work occasionally included reviewing materials outside her designated areas of responsibility.

The renewed scrutiny comes just two days after Senate Republicans advanced her nomination in a 15-0 committee vote. All 13 Democrats on the committee boycotted the proceedings after unsuccessfully seeking to delay the vote.

Thumann Severs’ nomination now awaits consideration by the full Senate. Meanwhile, Luján has given Carr until December 3 to produce the requested records.

Read the Luján’s letter to the FCC below:

Loading Viewer…

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *