As Chris Murphy writes in Vanity Fair, before it took the world by storm, “Domingo” nearly fell apart.

Appearing on Talk Easy With Sam Fragoso, Meyers recalled how Michaels offered him Late Night as if he was continuing a conversation they’d never had—positing (completely in jest) that Lorne has already “talked to himself” about who will succeed him at SNL, “and that person doesn’t know.”

A new first-look video reveals that the the pair are bringing their “feud” to an episode of this summer’s Kimmel-hosted Who Wants to be a Millionaire.