Wednesday’s episode of After Midnight could be its deadliest yet: Taylor Tomlinson is orchestrating a rematch between three contestants from The Traitors.
Dylan Efron, Bob the Drag Queen, and Tom Sandoval are all scheduled to appear on Wednesday night’s panel. Each of the three appeared together on Season 3 of The Traitors, though they each met very different fates over the course of the Peacock reality competition series’ eleven episodes.
Bob the Drag Queen was banished in the fourth episode, while Tom Sandoval lasted until the tenth episode before being murdered. Efron survived the entire season, becoming one of four winners when The Traitors wrapped its season on March 6.
Bob the Drag Queen has been a regular After Midnight guest since September 2024. This will be his fifth visit to the show, but the first appearance for both Efron and Sandoval.
In November, Tomlinson used Bob the Drag Queen’s second visit to stage another mini Traitors reunion. While the other panelists were not Traitors alums, fellow Season 3 contestant Chrishell Stause made a surprise walk-on to help lead a Traitors-inspired game called “Taylor’s Traitors.”
After Midnight has frequently used its panel format to stage theme episodes featuring castmates from current shows like Ghosts and Beyond the Gates and nostalgic reunions of past shows like All That and This Is Us. But the Traitors panel is a rare instance of Tomlinson reconvening the contestants of a competition show.
Will the panelists be given the opportunity to turn traitor and steal the others’ points? Viewers can tune into After Midnight’s Traitors reunion episode Wednesday, May 14th on CBS to find out.
