The taping was over.
On the evening of July 17, 2025, Stephen Colbert taped his show’s closing segment the way he had roughly 1,700 times before. His stage manager—a job Mark McKenna had held at Colbert’s side since The Colbert Report—told him they were done.
Colbert said no. There was one more act of the show, and nobody was to release the audience.
McKenna had the rundown in his hand. Everything on it had been shot. Four hundred people were sitting in the Ed Sullivan Theater with no idea why they were still there. As Colbert later recounted, he didn’t argue the point: “I am here to tell you there is one more act of the show.”
Then he went backstage and addressed his staff on a Zoom call.
The “one more act” had been in motion for weeks by then—just not anywhere Colbert could see it. To understand how it arrived at the Ed Sullivan Theater that evening, rewind ten weeks.
May: “I love our hand”
The first beat of the story, in hindsight, is an interview that read as reassurance at the time.
In early May 2025, CBS President and CEO George Cheeks told Deadline the network still believed in late night despite ending After Midnight at 12:35, after host Taylor Tomlinson opted to return to stand-up. The day part was “challenging from an ad sales perspective,” Cheeks allowed—but CBS had the number one show at 11:35, and “I love our hand,” he said.
Ten weeks later, the franchise was dead.
Late June–July 14: two tracks
By CBS’s later accounting, the decision came together in the early summer. The New York Times reported the show’s finances had been discussed in Paramount board meetings for a year—and that then-chair Shari Redstone wasn’t consulted on the cancellation itself.
When exactly CBS called Colbert’s longtime manager James “Baby Doll” Dixon with the news is unclear, but by all accounts he did not immediately tell Colbert.
The Late Show was on break at the time, and Colbert was on a European vacation—”drowning my entire life in spanakopita and Greek rosé,” he’d later quip. Colbert initially said Dixon was told “a couple of days” before he returned home, and later answered “something like that” when Jimmy Kimmel suggested it had been a week; Ankler’s reporting suggested something closer to two.
Meanwhile, on July 1, Paramount finalized its $16 million settlement of Donald Trump‘s lawsuit over a 60 Minutes interview—with the company’s Skydance merger still awaiting FCC approval. On Monday, July 14, his first night back from vacation, Colbert told his audience the settlement had a technical name in legal circles: “big fat bribe.”
Per every account since, he delivered that monologue not knowing his show had already been canceled.
July 16: fifteen minutes
The next day, Dixon asked for fifteen minutes in person after Wednesday night’s taping.
That was Colbert’s first sign. Dixon, Colbert later explained, never visited in person. “Five minutes on the phone with Baby Doll is an hour, so 15 minutes in person—what the hell is this about?” Colbert told his wife, Evie McGee-Colbert, he’d be home a little late.
The meeting ran at least two hours. Dixon told him this would be the show’s last season. Colbert recalls responding: “Really? Huh? Well, this comes as a surprise.”
The stated reason was money. Dixon relayed that the network said it was willing to open the books; Colbert declined. He was, he said, a company man—CBS ran the business, he ran the show.
He walked through his front door later that night and, by his own telling, Evie took one look at him: “What happened? You get canceled?”
Yes, he said. He did.
July 17, daytime: the sweat-through shirt
Colbert’s first instinct was to wait—tell the staff after the summer break. Evie was convinced he wouldn’t be able to do that, and rode to work with him the next morning.
“By the time I get to my offices, I have sweat through my shirt,” he told Kimmel in late September—the discomfort, as he explained it, of knowing something his staff didn’t. Even so, the circle stayed tiny through the day: Dixon, Evie, executive producer Tom Purcell, and the president of Colbert’s production company, Carrie Byalick. Telling everyone before taping, Colbert reasoned, would sink the show: everybody would be bummed out, and so would he.
So they shot a full episode—cold open, monologue, guests. Senator Adam Schiff, who would later denounce Colbert’s cancellation, happened to be on that night.
Then Colbert said good night, and asked the audience to stick around.
July 17, evening: the sentence that didn’t get a laugh
After the standoff with his stage manager, Colbert went backstage and gathered the staff on Zoom. His own description of that call is two sentences long: he told everybody as briefly as he could, so they’d find out before he announced it to the audience.
Then he walked back out and addressed the camera with nothing on the prompter.
He botched the announcement twice. The audience assumed it was a bit and started chanting encouragement—”You can do it. Come on, Steve. You can do it!”—as he kept stumbling on the same sentence. On the third try he got it out, the sentence that told them what was happening.
“They didn’t laugh,” he later explained. “That is it. That is how I did it.”
His taped announcement—”I found out just last night,” followed by “I’m not being replaced, this is all just going away”—replaced that night’s planned and produced cold open.
The video hit the internet hours before broadcast; the staff beat the world to the news by minutes. CBS’s statement, jointly attributed to Cheeks, Amy Reisenbach (President of CBS Entertainment), and David Stapf (President of CBS Studios), landed at the same time, calling it “purely a financial decision against a challenging backdrop in late night.”
The week after
Trump celebrated on Truth Social. Colbert responded with a suggestion that CBS could not have aired unbleeped. The July 21 episode packed the audience with his late-night peers—Jon Stewart, John Oliver, Jimmy Fallon, Seth Meyers, Andy Cohen—and his 12-minute monologue that night surpassed 10 million views on YouTube.
The July 17 episode itself drew 3.08 million viewers, the show’s largest audience of the calendar year to that point. The following week averaged 3 million, the show’s best raw numbers in over two years.
Within days, more than 200,000 people had signed petitions demanding CBS reverse course, many citing the three-day gap between “big fat bribe” and the announcement, and rallies formed outside the Ed Sullivan Theater.
On July 24, the FCC approved the Skydance-Paramount merger.
And on July 25—one day after the merger cleared—the man who built the franchise weighed in. In a video on his YouTube channel, David Letterman called his former network “gutless” for how it handled Colbert’s exit, and predicted the people behind the decision “are going to be embarrassed.” His read on the motive was blunter than any petition’s: “They don’t want any trouble from that guy.”
Cheeks addressed Colbert’s cancellation publicly for the first time on August 7, the day the deal closed: the late-night ad market was in “significant secular decline,” the show’s losses ran to the tens of millions—reportedly $40 million annually—and the July timing, he said, was driven by the seasonal cycle of writer and producer contract negotiations colliding with the final year of Colbert’s deal.
Colbert, for his part, has never disputed the network’s math—only observed, as he put it to the Times this spring, that less than two years earlier CBS had been eager to lock him down for a five-year contract. “So, something changed.”
Postscript: ten more months
The show Colbert promised his audience that night—same energy, to the end—largely delivered. There was a suppressed Talarico interview that did far bigger numbers on YouTube than it ever would have on CBS, two Emmys and a Writers Guild award, and a final season chock-full of heartfelt tributes.
And then there was May 21, 2026. The finale—Paul McCartney, “Hello, Goodbye,” the lights going out at the Ed Sullivan—drew 9.77 million in Live+7 viewers: the most-watched regular weeknight episode in the show’s history, behind only the 2016 post-Super Bowl broadcast overall. Measured by share, it beat even that—a third of everyone watching television at that hour watched Colbert say goodbye.
Get stories like this in your inbox: Sign up for LateNighter’s free daily newsletter.
