The SNL alum and the Late Show host met yesterday for the first time, but Colbert is already dropping the L bomb with McKinnon, who in turn confessed to being a Strangers With Candy superfan.

Fallon seemed to subtly acknowledge the mixed reaction to his primetime holiday special, showing off several good reviews and one not-so-good review. “Everyone’s got different opinions,” Fallon concluded.

The Gladiator II star has Chloe Fineman ready to ditch her boyfriend, and all it took were the words “I’m Paul Mescal and I’m hosting SNL this week with Shaboozey.”