Rarely does a single monologue joke say so much about the show telling it.
Seth Meyers’ three-night effort this week to perfect a throwaway joke was a perfect distillation of the show he’s made his own.
NBC’s Late Night is, of course, a late-night comedy show. But with Meyers at the helm, it’s also become a show about putting on a comedy show.
That’s most obvious in Corrections, Meyers’ weekly web series devoted to responding to viewer comments about the show, and in “Surprise Inspection,” where he reads rejected monologue jokes and (lovingly) calls out the writers behind them. But it also happens in smaller moments, when he questions his own delivery, notes cue card errors, or stops to pick apart why a bit did—or didn’t—work.
It feels especially natural coming from Meyers, who came up in improv and later spent eight years as head writer at Saturday Night Live. Reacting in the moment, dissecting a joke, and trying another version feel less like a format choice than muscle memory.
This week, all of that came together around one very dumb joke.
It started Monday with a news item about a woman suing a restaurant after allegedly finding a cow’s tooth in her food.
“A Texas woman has filed a lawsuit against the chain Torchy’s Tacos that claims she found a cow’s tooth in her food,” Meyers began. “‘Yes,’ said an employee, ‘a cow’s tooth.’”
The joke rested on the employee sounding less than convincing about whose tooth it actually was. The audience didn’t give it much of a response.
“That was my favorite one,” Meyers said. “I was trying so hard not to laugh the whole time.”
Rather than move on, he started workshopping the joke out loud.
“We should have had a graphic with a dude with just a big old tooth missing,” he said, before turning toward head writer Alex Baze, who was off camera. “Let’s do it again tomorrow.”
So they did.
Tuesday night, Meyers told the same joke again, this time accompanied by an over-the-shoulder image of a man conspicuously missing a tooth.
The crowd’s reaction was on par with the night before.
“Let’s do that one again tomorrow,” Meyers said. This time, though, he asked Baze to write an entirely new punchline and keep it from him until he reached it during Wednesday’s monologue.
“Just catch me off guard with it,” he said. “I think we’re gonna crack this one.”
By Wednesday, the workshopping had become the bit.
“Now, I should clarify, this is the third time this week we’ve told a joke about this story, because we’re just, like, fine tuning it,” Meyers told the audience.
He reminded them that he had asked Baze to surprise him with a rewrite, then tried the joke again.
“A Texas woman has filed a lawsuit against the chain Torchy’s Tacos that claimed she found a cow’s tooth in her food,” Meyers began.
He broke as he got his first look at the new punchline: “Even crazier, she found it in a fish taco.”
The audience laughed more heartily this time—at the joke, the three-night buildup, or both—and Meyers looked toward Baze. “You did it,” he said.
There’s recent precedent for a late-night host returning to the same monologue joke. Last winter, Jimmy Fallon repeatedly revisited the same Zohran Mamdani cold-weather punchline on The Tonight Show, eventually bringing Mamdani himself in on the gag.
But Meyers’ version was less about repetition than process. Over three nights, viewers got the original joke, the postmortem, the attempted fix, the rewrite, and finally the host encountering that rewrite in real time.
In other words, they didn’t just get the joke. They got to watch Late Night make it.
Get stories like this in your inbox: Sign up for LateNighter’s free daily newsletter.
