More than a month after Shane Gillis‘ SNL monologue sparked widespread backlash, NBC and Lorne Michaels have yet to publicly address the controversy. But the show’s repeat schedule may have just spoken for them.
On Saturday, Saturday Night Live announced that next weekend’s repeat will be its October 31 episode hosted by Inde Navarrette, passing over Gillis’ October 10 episode.
That’s unusual. SNL typically repeats episodes in the order they originally aired during breaks in the season; this is the first time in nearly three years that the show has departed from that pattern.
The previous two episodes it passed over had also sparked controversy.
The most recent was the December 9, 2023, episode hosted by Adam Driver with musical guest Olivia Rodrigo, which featured a widely criticized cold open parodying congressional testimony about antisemitism on college campuses.
Before that, it was the November 12, 2022, episode hosted by Dave Chappelle with musical guest Black Star, which drew accusations of antisemitism over jokes in Chappelle’s monologue.
Neither episode was ever rebroadcast on NBC, putting them in a very small group of SNL episodes to have aired only once on the network.
Whether Gillis’ episode will meet the same fate remains to be seen. NBC could still schedule it for a later repeat, and neither the network nor SNL has offered an explanation for the decision to pass it over. Still, given the show’s otherwise remarkably consistent repeat scheduling—and the precedent set by the Driver and Chappelle episodes—it’s difficult to dismiss the move as a coincidence.
Gillis’ October 10 monologue drew widespread criticism after the comedian joked that women at the gym were dressing “like whores.” The backlash extended beyond Gillis himself to SNL for giving the joke a national platform.
Gillis himself addressed the controversy publicly for the first time Friday during an appearance on The Joe Rogan Experience, where he where he seemed to distance SNL from responsibility for the offending material, revealing that he’d assured the show’s producers that his monologue wouldn’t cause any trouble
“The whole time, I was like, ‘Fellas, I’m giving you a solid C minus of a monologue, but I promise there’s no controversy,'” Gillis recalled.
He also pushed back against suggestions that SNL had approved his material beforehand, telling Rogan that stand-up comedians don’t submit their monologues for approval, although the show could stop them from performing material it considered objectionable.
Gillis’ full episode remains available to stream on Peacock, and his monologue is still posted on SNL‘s YouTube and social media pages. The same is true of the Chappelle and Driver episodes and their controversial segments, despite their absence from NBC’s repeat schedule.
There’s also an ironic twist to NBC’s choice of repeat: Navarrette’s October 31 show contains its own reference to Gillis’ controversial joke.
During her monologue, Navarrette discussed getting in shape for her upcoming role as Rogue in X-Men, telling the audience, “Every morning, I put on my little whore outfit and I hit the gym.”